By Nick Bartlett, Realtor and owner of Freedom Rental Property Management in Maple Grove, Minnesota.
I’m a Realtor and property manager, not a CPA. The tax rules here are the federal basics; your tax preparer decides how they apply to you.
Short answer: Should I sell or rent my house? Sell if you need the equity for your next home, if the rent won’t cover the mortgage, taxes, insurance and upkeep, or if you have a large gain you want to take tax-free. Rent if you have a low mortgage rate, the rent covers every cost with room to spare and you can hold the home for at least a few years. If you rent first, you have about 3 years after moving out to sell and still keep the home sale exclusion.
Key takeaways
- Selling a $400,000 home with a $250,000 mortgage and 7% in selling costs nets about $122,000 before taxes.
- The same $2,600 rent produces about $502 a month in cash flow on a 3.25% mortgage and loses about $142 a month on a 7% mortgage, after taxes, insurance, repairs, vacancy and management.
- The IRS lets you exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 married filing jointly) if you lived in the home at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, which leaves about a 3 year window to rent it first.
- Depreciation you claim while the home is a rental is taxed when you sell, at up to 25%, even when the rest of the gain is excluded.
- Minnesota rentals need a city rental license in Minneapolis, Brooklyn Park, Richfield and other Twin Cities cities, plus a landlord insurance policy.
Should I sell or rent my house in Minnesota?
The decision to sell or rent your house comes down to four numbers: what you’d walk away with from a sale, what the house would rent for, what it costs to own each month and how long you can hold it. Run all four before you list or before you sign a lease. Our rent vs sell calculator does the math with your own figures.
| Your situation | Sell the home | Rent the home |
|---|---|---|
| Need a down payment for your next home | You need the equity | You can buy without it |
| Your mortgage rate | High rate, small spread to rent | Low rate you can’t replace |
| Rent compared with monthly costs | Rent barely covers or misses costs | Rent covers costs with room to spare |
| Profit since you bought | Large gain you want tax-free | Modest gain, or you plan to keep it long term |
| Home condition | Big repairs due soon | Roof, furnace and AC in good shape |
| HOA restrictions | Rental cap or ban | Rentals allowed |
How much would you walk away with if you sell?
Your net proceeds from selling a house are the sale price minus the mortgage payoff and selling costs. Selling costs include the commissions you agree to, title and closing fees, the Minnesota deed tax the seller pays and any repairs or credits you give the buyer.
Here’s an example. A Maple Grove home sells for $400,000. The mortgage balance is $250,000. With 7% in total selling costs ($28,000), the owner walks away with about $122,000 before any tax on the gain. That $122,000 is the money a rental has to beat.
Would the rent cover your costs?
A rental makes sense only when the rent covers the mortgage, property tax, landlord insurance, repairs, vacancy and management with money left over. Take the same home renting for $2,600 a month:
- Mortgage principal and interest: $1,219 (30-year $280,000 loan at 3.25%)
- Property tax: $400
- Landlord insurance: $120
- Repair reserve at 5% of rent: $130
- Vacancy at 4% of rent: $104
- Management: $125 (our flat monthly fee)
That leaves about $502 a month in cash flow. Put the same house on a 7% mortgage and the payment jumps to $1,863, which turns the rental into a $142 monthly loss. The mortgage rate decides more rent-or-sell questions than anything else, and a rate under 4% is hard to give up.
Cash flow is only one way a rental pays. Mortgage paydown, appreciation and depreciation add to the return, and we walk through all four in Is Rental Property a Good Investment? If you don’t know what your house would rent for, start with a free rental analysis instead of an online estimate.
What happens to your tax-free gain if you rent the house first?
The home sale exclusion lets you skip tax on up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly, when you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. The rules are in IRS Topic 701 and Publication 523.
Because the test looks back 5 years from the sale date, an owner who lived in the home for 2 years can rent it for up to about 3 years and still qualify. Sell after that window closes and the whole gain is taxable.
Depreciation recapture is the tax on the depreciation you claimed, or could have claimed, while the home was a rental. The exclusion never covers it, and it’s taxed at up to 25% when you sell. Our guide to the tax side of turning your Minnesota home into a rental covers depreciation, rental losses and Minnesota’s property tax classes in detail.
When does selling your house make more sense than renting it?
- You need the equity. If buying your next home depends on this sale, sell.
- The rent doesn’t cover the costs. A home that loses money every month only works if it appreciates fast, and that’s a bet, not a plan.
- You have a large gain and a short window. If you’ve already been out of the home for close to 3 years, renting longer can turn a tax-free gain into a taxable one.
- Big repairs are coming. A 20-year-old furnace and an original roof can eat several years of cash flow.
- The HOA restricts rentals. Twin Cities townhome associations can cap the number of rentals or require a minimum lease term. Read your covenants before you plan on renting.
When does renting your house make more sense than selling?
- Your mortgage rate is low. A rate under 4% is the strongest reason we see owners keep the house.
- The house rents well. A 2 to 3 bedroom detached home in a good school district draws the largest pool of renters in the Twin Cities.
- You might move back. A job relocation for 2 or 3 years is a natural fit for a rental, as long as the lease end lines up with your return.
- You don’t need the cash. If you can buy your next home without the equity, the house can keep paying down its own mortgage.
- The house won’t sell for what you need. If you’re facing another price cut, read why your house isn’t selling and when renting it makes sense.
Can you rent your house now and sell it later?
Yes, and a lot of the owners we work with do exactly that: rent for one to three years, then sell inside the home sale exclusion window or keep it longer if the numbers are good. Three things make the later sale easier.
- Time the lease end. End the lease in late spring or early summer, when buyer traffic peaks, so you can sell the home vacant and clean.
- Know the showing rules. Minnesota law lets a landlord enter to show the home to a buyer with at least 24 hours’ notice, between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., under Minn. Stat. 504B.211.
- Keep records. Save every repair invoice and improvement receipt. Improvements raise your cost basis and lower the taxable gain.
If you plan to sell when the lease ends, tell your property manager before the renewal comes up. That way the lease end date, the move-out inspection and any repairs line up with the listing instead of costing you an extra month of holding costs.
Should you manage the rental yourself or hire a property manager?
Managing a rental yourself saves the management fee, but for one or two rentals it isn’t worth learning the job. Property management is a part-time job with its own training, software, vendors and legal rules, and Minnesota law leans hard toward tenants. Our advice for an owner with one rental: leave it to the professionals.
How much does a property manager cost in Minnesota?
Less than owners expect. We charge a flat $125 a month per rental, with no markups on repairs, and the full breakdown is on our pricing page. Percentage-based managers charge 8% to 12% of the rent, which is $240 a month at 10% on a $2,400 rental. Our guide How Much Do Property Managers Charge in Minnesota? compares the fee models side by side.
Why are first-time landlords at a disadvantage in Minnesota?
- The law keeps changing. Minnesota rewrites its landlord-tenant rules nearly every legislative session. See our summaries of the 2024 and 2025 Minnesota rental law changes.
- Screening rules are strict. A landlord must disclose screening criteria before taking an application fee, tell a rejected applicant within 14 days which criteria they missed and can’t deny an applicant for an eviction filing that didn’t end in a writ of recovery (Minn. Stat. 504B.173).
- Missed steps cost money. A late deposit return can cost up to $500 in punitive damages on top of the deposit (Minn. Stat. 504B.178), and an eviction notice with a missing step gets the case dismissed and starts the clock over.
- Experienced tenants know the rules better than you. Our article on how to handle professional tenants shows how a tenant can live rent-free for months while an owner learns the process.
- Repairs need a response that day. No heat in January is an emergency, and a landlord who lets it slide can face a rent escrow action in housing court. See the risks of doing your own maintenance.
An eviction with legal fees, lost rent and repairs costs an owner $8,000 to $14,000 in our experience, and the evictions we file are mostly for new clients who tried to manage on their own first. Compare that with $125 a month. See what a property manager does, or read our step-by-step guide on how to rent out your house if you still want to try it yourself.
Frequently asked questions
Should I sell or rent my house if I have a low mortgage rate?
A low mortgage rate is the strongest reason to rent your house instead of selling. In our example, the same $2,600 rent produces about $502 a month in cash flow at a 3.25% rate and loses about $142 a month at 7%. Confirm with your lender that your loan allows renting the home after you move out.
How long can I rent out my house and still avoid capital gains tax?
You can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 married filing jointly) if you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. An owner who lived in the home for 2 years has about 3 years after moving out to sell and keep the exclusion. Depreciation claimed while renting is still taxed at up to 25%.
Is it better to sell or rent my house in Minnesota?
It’s better to sell when you need the equity, the rent won’t cover your costs or you have a large gain and a short tax window. It’s better to rent when your mortgage rate is low, the rent covers every cost with room to spare and you can hold the home for a few years. Freedom Rental Property Management can tell you what your home would rent for before you decide.
What does it cost to rent out my house instead of selling it?
Plan for property tax, a landlord insurance policy, a repair reserve of about 5% of the rent, vacancy of about 4% of the rent, a city rental license where required and a management fee if you hire a manager. Twin Cities cities including Minneapolis and Brooklyn Park require a rental license and inspection.
Can I rent my house while it’s listed for sale?
You can, but it rarely works well. Tenants want a 12 month lease and buyers want a vacant home, so the listing and the rental work against each other. Cancel the listing before a property manager markets the home for rent, then decide on a sale when the lease ends.
Not sure whether to sell or rent? Freedom Rental Property Management manages rental homes across the Twin Cities, from Maple Grove and Plymouth to Minneapolis. We’ll tell you what your home would rent for and what it would cost to run, so you can compare it with a sale.
Try the rent vs sell calculator, request a free rental analysis or contact us. See our full service area.