How Much Do Property Managers Charge in Minnesota?

How much do property managers charge, 10 percent costing $2,880 a year versus a $125 flat fee at $1,500

By Nick Bartlett, Realtor and owner of Freedom Rental Property Management in Maple Grove, Minnesota.

Short answer: Most property managers charge 8% to 12% of the monthly rent they collect, and 10% is the number you’ll hear most. On a $2,400 per month rental in the Twin Cities, 10% is $240 a month, or $2,880 a year, and that’s before leasing fees and maintenance markups. Freedom Rental Property Management charges a flat $125 a month instead, with no percentage and no markup on maintenance invoices.

Key takeaways

  • The standard property management fee in the United States is 8% to 12% of collected rent, and 10% is the benchmark.
  • A percentage fee goes up every time your rent goes up. The work doesn’t.
  • Tenant placement is billed separately at 50% to 100% of one month’s rent, and lease renewals run $200 to $500.
  • We charge 50% of one month’s rent for tenant placement, with a $995 minimum, the bottom of that range.
  • Some managers add 10% to 15% to every repair invoice. It’s the fee owners miss most when comparing companies.
  • We charge $125 a month flat and $400 at renewal ($200 for the lease renewal plus $200 for the annual inspection), with nothing added to maintenance invoices.
  • A flat fee isn’t always cheaper. Below $1,250 in monthly rent, a 10% fee costs less than $125 a month.

How much do property managers charge in Minnesota?

Most property managers charge 8% to 12% of the monthly rent collected, and 10% is the industry benchmark (DoorLoop, property management fees by state). Minnesota has no cap on what a property manager can charge, so the market sets the rate.

The percentage is only part of the bill. Property management pricing is built from four charges: the monthly management fee, a tenant placement (leasing) fee, a lease renewal fee, and any markup on maintenance invoices. Two companies can both quote 10% and be a thousand dollars apart by the end of the year.

Here’s what bugs me about the percentage model. It’s tied to the rent, not the work. Collecting $2,600 takes exactly as much effort as collecting $2,400, but the manager gets paid more for it.

When you compare managers, put all five charges in one column: monthly management, tenant placement, lease renewal, the annual inspection and any maintenance markup. A low monthly fee paired with a high leasing fee and a 15% markup on every repair costs more by the end of the year than a flat fee with no markups.

The five property management charges: monthly management, tenant placement, lease renewal, annual inspection, maintenance markup

What does a percentage management fee cost on a Twin Cities rental?

Annual management fee on a $2,400 rental, $2,880 at 10 percent versus $1,500 on a flat fee

A 10% management fee on a $2,400 per month rental costs $240 a month, which is $2,880 a year. We use $2,400 because it sits right in the middle of what we see in the north and west Twin Cities suburbs: three bedroom single family homes rent for $2,100 to $2,600, and four bedrooms for $2,350 to $2,880.

Our fee on that same rental is $125 a month, or $1,500 a year. That’s $1,380 a year less on the management line alone.

The gap grows as rent rises. At $2,900 a month, 10% is $290 a month and $3,480 a year. Our fee is still $125 a month and $1,500 a year, so the difference is now $1,980. Owners rarely think about this when they sign. The percentage looks the same on paper, but every rent increase gives the manager a raise too.

What other property management fees should you expect?

Beyond the monthly fee, expect a tenant placement fee, a lease renewal fee, a setup fee, and at some companies a markup on maintenance invoices. Tenant placement runs 50% to 100% of one month’s rent, lease renewals run $200 to $500, and some managers add 10% to 15% to every repair bill (DoorLoop).

The maintenance markup is the one owners miss. If your rental needs $4,000 of repairs in a year and the manager adds 12%, you just paid $480 for an invoice passing through someone’s hands. We don’t mark up maintenance invoices, and it’s also one reason we don’t work with home warranty companies.

Here’s how the two pricing models compare on a $2,400 per month Twin Cities rental. The percentage column uses a 10% management fee, a tenant placement fee of 75% of one month’s rent, a $350 lease renewal and a 12% markup on $4,000 of repairs. Those are the midpoints of the published ranges, not a quote from any one company.

ChargeTypical percentage modelFreedom Rental Property Management
Monthly management (12 months)$2,880$1,500
Tenant placement (one turnover)$1,800$1,200
Maintenance markup on $4,000 of repairs$480$0
First year total with one turnover$5,160$2,700
Lease renewal (instead of a turnover)$350$200
Annual inspection with photo reportRarely offered$200
Year total with a renewal instead$3,710$1,900

A note on our renewal line. We charge $400 at renewal, and it’s two separate services: $200 for the lease renewal and $200 for an annual inspection with a full interior and exterior photo report and a fresh market rent analysis. The $200 renewal by itself is at the bottom of the $200 to $500 market range.

One fee isn’t in the table. Several north and west metro cities require a city rental license inspection, and we charge a flat $110 to meet the inspector, walk the property and handle the follow up. It only applies when the city requires an inspection. Our full fee schedule is on the property management pricing page.

What a full year actually costs

On a $2,400 per month Twin Cities rental with one tenant turnover, a typical percentage model costs $5,160 in the first year. With us it’s $2,700. That’s $2,460 back in your pocket: $1,380 on monthly management, $600 on tenant placement and $480 on maintenance markup.

The typical percentage model in that example adds up three charges: $2,880 in monthly management at 10%, a $1,800 leasing fee at 75% of one month’s rent and a $480 markup at 12% on $4,000 of repairs. Our total is $1,500 in management plus a $1,200 leasing fee at 50% of one month’s rent, with no markup.

A tenant turnover is where the fee gap shows up most. Every turnover triggers a new leasing fee, and the repairs to get the house ready carry the markup. Ask any manager you interview to price out a year with one turnover on your house, in dollars.

First year property management cost, $5,160 on a percentage model versus $2,700 with Freedom

Why charge a flat fee instead of a percentage of rent?

We charge a flat $125 a month because managing a rental doesn’t get harder when the rent goes up. Collecting rent, coordinating maintenance, answering resident questions, taking after hours calls and sending owner statements is the same work on a $1,800 townhome as on a $2,900 house.

A percentage also creates an awkward incentive at renewal. If the manager earns 10% of rent, a rent increase is a raise for the manager. That’s fine when the market supports it and not fine when it doesn’t. With a flat fee, our rent recommendation is about one thing: what your home will actually lease for.

Same with maintenance. A manager taking a markup on repairs makes more when repairs cost more. We make nothing on your maintenance invoices, so our interests and yours point the same direction on every repair. If you’re thinking about doing repairs yourself instead, I wrote about rental owners doing their own maintenance.

Not everything we charge is flat. Tenant placement is 50% of one month’s rent with a $995 minimum, the same structure most companies use, at the bottom of the 50% to 100% range. The $995 minimum kicks in on rentals below $1,990 a month.

Is a flat fee always cheaper than a percentage?

Flat fee versus 10 percent management fee by monthly rent, showing the break even near $1,250

No. A flat $125 fee equals 10% of $1,250 in rent, so on a rental below $1,250 a month, a 10% fee costs less than ours. If you own small apartments or rooms that rent below that, a percentage manager will save you money, and I’ll tell you that on the phone.

Above $1,250 a month, the flat fee wins, and the gap grows with the rent. Single family homes in the north and west Twin Cities suburbs rent for $2,100 to $2,900, well past that line. At $2,400 a month the flat fee saves $1,380 a year on management alone. At $1,100 a month, 10% is $110 and the flat fee is $125, so the percentage model wins by $180 a year.

The only fair way to compare two managers is to add up every charge for a full year on your property, including a turnover if you expect one. A free rental analysis tells you what your home should rent for, and that’s the number the whole comparison hangs on.

What should you check before hiring a property manager in Minnesota?

Check that the company holds a Minnesota real estate license, get the complete fee schedule in writing, and ask point blank whether maintenance invoices carry a markup. Minnesota Statute 82.55, subdivision 19(a), includes anyone who for compensation “lists, sells, exchanges, buys or rents, manages” real estate in the definition of a real estate broker (Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes). Managing someone else’s rental for a fee in Minnesota requires a license.

Five questions to ask any manager you interview:

  1. What is the total of every fee I would pay in a year with one tenant turnover, in dollars?
  2. Do you add a markup or coordination fee to maintenance invoices, and what is the percentage?
  3. What is the leasing fee, and is it charged again if the tenant leaves within the first year?
  4. Does the renewal fee include an inspection with photos and a market rent analysis?
  5. Are you licensed with the Minnesota Department of Commerce, and under which brokerage?

Ask for the answers in dollars, not percentages. “Ten percent” sounds small. “$2,880 a year” is something you can compare. For a fuller picture of the job itself, here’s what a property manager does.

Five questions to ask a property manager about total yearly cost, markups, leasing and licensing

Frequently asked questions

What is the average property management fee?

The average property management fee in the United States is 8% to 12% of monthly rent collected, and 10% is the benchmark. On a $2,400 per month rental that’s $192 to $288 a month. Flat fee companies are the alternative. Freedom Rental Property Management charges $125 a month regardless of rent.

Are property management fees charged on collected rent or scheduled rent?

It depends on the contract, and it matters. A fee on collected rent means the manager earns nothing during a vacancy or a month the tenant doesn’t pay. A fee on scheduled rent is owed whether the rent shows up or not. Find that sentence in the agreement before you sign.

Do property managers charge a fee when the property is vacant?

Some do. Some companies bill a reduced vacancy fee of $50 to $75 a month while a unit sits empty, and others charge nothing until a tenant is placed. Ask directly, because a vacancy fee can run for months during a slow winter leasing season.

Is a property management fee tax deductible in Minnesota?

Yes. Property management fees are a deductible operating expense on a rental, reported on Schedule E of your federal return (IRS Topic No. 414), and Minnesota follows the federal treatment. I’m not a CPA, so confirm the details for your situation with your tax preparer.

How much does tenant placement cost separately from management?

Tenant placement costs 50% to 100% of one month’s rent, which on a $2,400 rental is $1,200 to $2,400. We charge 50% of one month’s rent with a $995 minimum, so $1,200 on that rental. That covers marketing, showings, screening, the lease and the move in inspection.

Can I negotiate property management fees?

At some companies, yes, especially if you bring several properties. We don’t negotiate, and that’s on purpose. Our fees are set as low as we can make them from the start, and every owner pays the same rate whether they have one rental or twenty. If a company drops its price the moment you push back, ask yourself what the first quote was.

If you own a rental in the north or west Twin Cities suburbs and want a straight dollar comparison against what you pay now, we’ll run the numbers with you. Start with a free rental analysis to find out what your home should rent for, or contact us and we’ll go through the fee schedule line by line.

Picture of Nick Bartlett

Nick Bartlett

Real Estate Investor and Property Manager

Freedom Rental Property Management is owned and operated by a rental property investor, just like you. We run every home the way we'd want our own rentals managed: clear communication, careful tenant screening, flat fees with no markups, and every decision made as if it were our own money on the line.

Facebook
LinkedIn